The Ignite Press Blog

image of people gathered at table with pencil and paper

From Manuscript to Masterpiece: How to Maximize Your Book's Potential with Effective Editorial Feedback

January 23, 20242 min read

"Using an Editorial Board... provides you with comprehensive Developmental Edits and ensures that your book will meet the readers’ needs and serve as a valuable tool." - Cathy Fyock

Writing a book can be an exciting and fulfilling endeavor, but it doesn't end there. Once you've completed your manuscript, the next step is to seek feedback from others who can give you an honest and constructive critique. This is where editorial boards come in. Editorial boards can provide valuable feedback and support for writers looking to improve their work.

In this article, we'll explore the importance of editorial boards and provide tips on how to get the most out of their feedback. Whether you're a first-time author or a seasoned writer, the feedback you receive from an editorial board can make all the difference in the success of your book.

Here are a few tips to maximize the benefits of your editorial board!

Be clear about your expectations

It's essential to be transparent about your expectations with your editorial board to help manage feedback. Share your goal with your editorial board and ask them to provide detailed feedback rather than general comments. Provide them with a timeline, deadline, and specific questions or areas you want them to focus on when reviewing your manuscript. This structure will keep everyone on the same page and ensure you receive the feedback you need to move forward with your manuscript.

Don't take criticism personally

It's important to remember that your editorial board members are there to help you improve your manuscript, not attack you personally. Some feedback may be difficult to hear, but it's necessary to improve your book's quality. Always approach feedback constructively and use it to strengthen your writing and storytelling skills. Try not to take feedback personally and instead view it as an opportunity for growth.

Thank your editorial board

After you've received feedback from your editorial board, always respond and engage with them. Thank them for their time and effort, clarify any misunderstandings, or ask for additional feedback on specific areas. Seeking to better understand the feedback they've given you can help you hone your skills as a writer.


Having a strong editorial board can immensely improve the quality of your book. The feedback and guidance of a diverse group of experts can help you identify blind spots, expand your horizons, and refine your writing. However, to make the most out of your editorial board, you need to approach it strategically and collaboratively. You should establish clear expectations, timelines, and roles for everyone involved, and communicate openly and respectfully throughout the process. Also, be open to constructive criticism, flexible in incorporating suggested changes, and grateful for the collective effort of the board.

By following these tips, you can not only get the best feedback for your book but also enhance your skills as a writer and build valuable relationships with your peers!

Back to Blog

Schedule your book consultation now...

TAKE ACTION TODAY

Sit down with International Best-selling author Everett O'Keefe to discuss your book idea and what a book can do for your brand and business. 


During your consultation, you can discuss:

  • Bestseller Campaigns!

  • Titles and Subtitles!

  • Cover Ideas and Options!

  • Book Creation Strategies!

  • Much, more!

Book a time with Everett

 EVERETT O'KEEFE

TAKE ACTION TODAY

Sit down with International Best-selling author Everett O'Keefe to discuss your book idea and what a book can do for your brand and business.  During your consultation, you can discuss:
  • Best Seller Campaigns!
  • Titles and Subtitles!
  • Cover Ideas and Options!
  •  Book Creation Strategies!
  •  And much more!

Schedule your book consultation now...

Book a time with Everett

EVERETT O'KEEFE

IGNITE PRESS IS A PROUD MEMBER OF

Author email: CLICK HERE